Why do progressives help Democrats? Half one

John C. Goodman

November 15, 06:00 AM November 15, 06:12 AM

Did you understand that an important "progressive" reform concepts of the final half-century haven't come from the Left? They've come from Republican politicians and right-of-center intellectuals and assume tanks. Here's a transient abstract.

Tax reform. A typical chorus from liberal critics is that Republican tax reform payments inevitably imply tax cuts for the wealthy. However do you know that the U.S. tax system is probably the most progressive amongst all developed nations? Greater than every other developed nation, we tax the rich excess of poor and middle-income households. We're much more progressive than the social welfare states of Northern Europe. This reality will not be controversial. It's accepted by economists of all political persuasions. Furthermore, greater than half of all households immediately pay no earnings tax in any respect. That’s as a result of each Republican tax invoice — going all the best way again to Ronald Reagan — threw increasingly folks off the earnings tax rolls.

Unfavorable Revenue Tax. Not solely is our tax system extra progressive than different nations, however our total welfare system can also be extra progressive. That's, we distribute extra from the highest to the underside than every other nation. Different nations could have extra social insurance coverage, however now we have extra redistribution.

Probably the most vital autos for lowering poverty relies on the concept of a damaging earnings tax, proposed by Milton Friedman in 1962. The legislative model, first launched in 1975, known as the Earned Revenue Tax Credit score. Carefully associated is the little one tax credit score, created by a Republican Congress in 1997. Due to these two measures, by 2018 it was just about unimaginable for a working mom to be poor (when it comes to money earnings), even when she earned solely the minimal wage! Underneath the Battle on Poverty — originated by Democrats within the Nineteen Sixties — healthcare cash goes to docs and hospitals; housing cash goes to landlords and builders; meals stamp cash goes to agribusiness; schooling cash goes to highschool bureaucracies, and so forth.

What distinction does this make? The particular pursuits use their political affect to form and mould the construction of those applications for his or her profit — not for the advantage of low-income households. Research discover that Medicaid enrollees, for instance, worth their protection at as little as 20 cents on the greenback. Against this, each refundable tax credit score greenback is price a greenback.

Common well being protection. Many readers will do not forget that within the 2008 presidential marketing campaign Barack Obama promised well being reform. After his election victory, we obtained Obamacare. However have you learnt that his opponent, the late Sen. John McCain (R-AZ), proposed a far extra expansive well being reform?

The Obama exchanges have by no means included greater than 20 million folks. However McCain’s plan would have straight affected 10 instances that quantity. In a nutshell, McCain proposed to take all the federal government cash at present within the system (all tax and spending subsidies for personal medical insurance) and provides each American a refundable tax credit score for medical insurance and healthcare. Obamacare sends cash to insurance coverage corporations and imposes all types of top-down regulation. As an alternative, McCain’s plan would have despatched the cash to households and let market competitors meet their wants. Whereas Obamacare made the federal government larger, McCain would have made the federal government higher.

Apparently, when Obama obtained to the White Home, a few of his advisers tried to persuade him to undertake the McCain method. Sadly, he had already campaigned on the declare that McCain’s method was "too radical."

I’ll have extra examples in my subsequent column on Tuesday.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM RESTORING AMERICA

John Goodman is the president and CEO of the Goodman Institute and Senior Fellow on the Unbiased Institute.